The Chevrolet Silverado is a truck icon, but not every year is a winner. Some models shine, while others are best overlooked.
Ready for a deep dive into Silverado history?
We’ve crunched data from NHTSA, Consumer Reports, and real owners to create a no-nonsense guide to the best and worst Silverado years.
Buckle up – we’re about to take you on an expedition through Chevy’s pickup evolution, showing you which models to grab and which to avoid.
Table of ContentsShow
Chevrolet Silverado Generations
The Chevrolet Silverado isn’t just a truck; it’s a heritage on wheels. Since 1999, this American workhorse has evolved through four separate generations, each bringing its own flavor to the pickup party.
Here’s a quick rundown of the Silverado’s family tree:
| Generation | Years |
|---|---|
| 1st generation (GMT800) | 1999-2006 |
| 2nd generation (GMT900) | 2007-2013 |
| 3rd generation (GMTK2XX) | 2014-2018 |
| 4th generation (GMTT1XX) | 2019-Present |
Knowing these generations is like having a roadmap to Silverado success. Each era brings its own strengths and quirks, and understanding them could be the difference between driving off in a dream machine or a lemon.
Chevrolet Silverado Best, Neutral, and Worst Years
When it comes to picking a Silverado, you’ve got to separate the wheat from the chaff. We’ve crunched the numbers, pored over reports, and listened to the real experts – the owners themselves. Our data comes from a smorgasbord of reliable sources:
- Owner-reported reliability surveys
- Annual maintenance costs
- Safety ratings
- Consumer Reports reliability and satisfaction scores
- NHTSA recalls, investigations, and complaints
- Edmunds, JD Power, Kelley’s Blue Book (KBB), VehicleHistory, and Cars.com owner ratings
Think of it as a Silverado report card, where we’ve done the homework so you don’t have to.
Now, let’s break it down into the good, the okay, and the ugly:
| Generation | Best Years | Neutral Years | Worst Years |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1st generation (GMT800) | 2004 2006 | 2002 2003 | 1999 2000 2001 2005 |
| 2nd generation (GMT900) | 2007 2008 2011 2013 | N/A | 2009 2010 2012 |
| 3rd generation (GMTK2XX) | 2018 2017 | 2016 | 2014 2015 |
| 4th generation (GMTT1XX) | 2020 2023 | 2019 | 2021 2022 |
Remember, “Neutral Years” are like the C students of the Silverado world – not terrible, but not winning any commendations either. They’re the years that flew under the radar, avoiding major issues but not exactly setting the truck world alight.
And here’s a pro tip: when we talk about “worst years,” we’re looking at things like frequent recalls and a chorus of owner complaints. More recalls mean less reliability, and that’s a red flag in our book.
Ready to dig deeper?
Let’s roll up our sleeves and get into the fine points of each generation.
Best & Worst Years for Chevrolet Silverado 1st Generation (1999-2006)
The first-gen Silverado burst onto the scene in 1999, ready to take on the new millennium. It was tough, it was capable, but it wasn’t without its growing pains. Buckle up, because this generation has more recalls than a politician has promises.
The Best Years: 2004, 2006
In the world of first-gen Silverados, 2004 and 2006 are the cool kids. These models stepped up their game with better safety features, improved fuel efficiency, and tech upgrades that made driving a pleasure, not a chore.
The 2006 model, in particular, saw complaints drop faster than a lead balloon. It’s like Chevy finally got the memo and started listening to their customers. The 2004 model, while still wrestling with some electrical gremlins, proved itself a road warrior that owners could trust.
The Neutral Years: 2002, 2003
The 2002 Silverado was like that reliable friend who’s always there but never really stands out. It kept chugging along, offering decent value despite some lingering brake issues.
Fun fact: the 2002 Silverado 2500HD even snagged J.D. Power’s award for most dependable heavy-duty full-size pickup in 2005. Not too shabby for a middle-of-the-road year.
2003 took a bit of a tumble, though. Electrical issues started creeping in, with dashboard failures leading the charge of complaints. It wasn’t a disaster, but it wasn’t winning any popularity contests either.
The Worst Years: 1999, 2000, 2001, 2005
Ah, the troublemakers of the first generation. The 1999 model came out swinging – and not in a positive way. A whopping 50% of its 1,722 NHTSA complaints were about brake problems. Talk about a rocky start.
The 2000 and 2001 models decided to keep the party going, adding engine and transmission woes to the mix. It’s like they were trying to hit complaint bingo.
2005, despite being sandwiched between two good years, couldn’t shake off the electrical demons that plagued its predecessors.
If you’re eyeing a truck from this era, do yourself a favor and check that VIN. You don’t want to drive off in a recall nightmare.
Best & Worst Years for Chevrolet Silverado 2nd Generation (2007-2013)
The second-gen Silverado rolled onto the scene in 2007, bringing a fresh mix of reliability and innovation. This generation saw fewer recalls and complaints, proving that Chevy was learning from past mistakes.
Let’s break it down.
The Best Years: 2007, 2008, 2011, 2013
2007 was a game-changer for the Silverado. Chevy decided it was time for the truck to be more family-friendly, and boy, did they deliver. This model was the first to score a “Good” rating from the IIHS in its overlap front crash test. Talk about a safety upgrade!
The 2007 redesign wasn’t just about looks – it was a triple threat of performance, safety, and reliability. Consumer Reports gave it a thumbs up, with high owner satisfaction scores to boot.
2008 kept the ball rolling, though it wasn’t all smooth sailing. There were some hiccups with airbags and electrical systems, but the pros still outweighed the cons. Chevy even launched a proactive recall for 857,000 vehicles, including the 2007-2008 Silverado, to fix a potential electrical issue. That’s what we call taking responsibility.
Fast forward to 2011, and the Silverado was hitting its stride. This model year brought tech upgrades, better safety features, and engines that could really pack a punch. It was like Chevy took everything good about the previous years and cranked it up a notch.
Closing out the generation, the 2013 Silverado was the refined older sibling of the bunch. Better fuel efficiency, a hushed cabin, and a comfortable ride made this model a favorite among drivers. Whether you were hauling cargo or cruising down the highway, the 2013 Silverado had you covered.
The Worst Years: 2009, 2010, 2012
Now, let’s talk about the not-so-great years. The 2009 Silverado hit a bit of a speed bump. While it wasn’t a total disaster, owners reported issues with build quality and some mechanical hiccups. It was like the truck was going through an awkward teenage phase.
The 2010 model continued this trend. It didn’t have a ton of complaints, but it also didn’t wow anyone. Think of it as the vanilla ice cream of trucks – not bad, but not exactly exciting either.
2012 was a mixed bag. It was reliable in many ways, but it didn’t shine as brightly as its siblings. Some owners grumbled about electrical glitches and transmission quirks. Nothing major, but enough to keep it off our “best of” list.
Best & Worst Years for Chevrolet Silverado 3rd Generation (2014-2018)
The third-gen Silverado rolled out in 2014, promising high-tech features, better safety, and a sleeker look. But did it deliver?
Let’s explore.
The Best Years: 2017, 2018
2017 was the Silverado’s year to shine. This truck was a powerhouse, offering a perfect blend of muscle and fuel efficiency. It even snagged Kelley Blue Book’s “5-Year Cost to Own” and “Best Resale Value” awards in the full-size pickup category. Talk about holding its value!
Safety features? Check. Apple CarPlay and Android Auto? You bet. Powerful engine options? Absolutely. The 2017 model was ticking all the right boxes for critics and drivers alike.
The 2018 Silverado took everything great about the 2017 model and cranked it up a notch. It came loaded with modern tech, a smoother ride, and could tow like nobody’s business.
This model year was amassing awards like a kid collects baseball cards. J.D. Power’s “#1 in Large Light Duty Pickup“? Got it. Kelley Blue Book’s “Best Resale Value“? In the bag. And let’s not forget the NHTSA’s “5-Star Overall Vehicle Rating“. If there was an award for winning awards, the 2018 Silverado would’ve won that too.
The Neutral Years: 2016
The 2016 Silverado was like the middle child of the third generation – not bad, but not stealing the spotlight either. It offered solid performance, decent fuel efficiency, and fewer headaches for owners.
Chevy gave it a mini facelift and some new tech features, keeping it fresh without reinventing the wheel. It’s the kind of truck that gets the job done without much fuss – reliable, but not revolutionary.
The Worst Years: 2014, 2015
Oh boy, 2014. As the inaugural year for the third generation, it had some big shoes to fill. Unfortunately, it stumbled right out of the gate. The NHTSA complaint box was overflowing, with gripes about everything from engine troubles to steering problems.
With 20 recalls under its belt, the 2014 model was keeping mechanics busier than a one-armed wallpaper hanger. Issues ranged from power train hiccups to faulty seat assemblies. Not exactly the robust start Chevy was hoping for.
The 2015 Silverado didn’t fare much better. It was like Groundhog Day for Chevy, with similar issues popping up again. Engine and transmission problems were still the headliners, and the recall train kept on rolling.
But here’s the silver lining: Chevy was listening. These early fumbles set the stage for the improvements we saw in later years. Sometimes you’ve got to stumble before you can sprint, right?
Best & Worst Years for Chevrolet Silverado 4th Generation (2019-Present)
The fourth-gen Silverado hit the streets in 2019, promising to be the cleverest, strongest, and most advanced yet. But did it live up to the hype? Let’s break it down.
The Best Years: 2020, 2023
2020 was the year Chevy really hit its stride with the Silverado. This truck wasn’t just turning heads; it was winning hearts (and awards). Cars.com and Kelley Blue Book both crowned the 2020 Silverado HD as the “Best Pickup Truck of 2020“. Not too shabby, Chevy!
Safety features? The 2020 model had them in spades. From forward-collision alerts to blind-spot monitoring, this truck was looking out for you. And let’s talk about that interior – more legroom in the back, a tech-loaded cabin with the Chevrolet Infotainment 3 system, and even a Wi-Fi hotspot. It’s like they squeezed a mobile office into a pickup truck.
But the 2020 Silverado wasn’t just about comfort and tech. When it came to towing and engine options, this truck flexed hard. It was the Swiss Army knife of pickups – versatile, powerful, and ready for anything.
The Neutral Years: 2019
The 2019 Silverado was like a rookie player in their first big game – full of potential, but still finding its footing. As the debut year of the fourth generation, it brought a fresh design and some nifty weight-reduction tricks to the table.
Chevy supersized the bed and cabin, giving you more space for… well, everything. The tech offerings, like the innovative infotainment system and smartphone compatibility, were a success with drivers.
Sure, it had a few hiccups here and there, but overall, the 2019 Silverado laid a sturdy foundation for the years to come. Think of it as the opening act that got everyone thrilled for the main event.
The Worst Years: 2021, 2022
Now, let’s talk about the troublemakers of the fourth generation. The 2021 Silverado hit a few bumps in the road, with owners raising red flags about engine and powertrain issues. These weren’t just minor annoyances – we’re talking about problems that had drivers dialing up their mechanics more often than they’d like.
The 2022 model? Well, it seems like it didn’t get the memo from 2021. The identical gremlins in the engine and powertrain decided to stick around for another year. These weren’t just inconveniences; they were potential safety concerns that had owners (and Chevy) perspiring.
It just goes to show that even with all the advancements and improvements, there’s always room for, well, more improvement. Here’s hoping Chevy takes these lessons to heart for future models.
Chevrolet Silverado Average Resale Values
Want to know how well your Silverado might maintain its value? Check out this graph showing average resale values across different model years:
Conclusion
We’ve covered the Silverado’s best and worst. For budget-friendly options, aim for 2007-2013. Want newer? 2017 and 2018 are top picks.
Now, it’s your turn: Which Silverado year would you choose, and why? First-gen fan or tech-lover?
Share your Silverado stories in the comments.
Your practical experience is invaluable for anyone picking their perfect truck.
